Blog Post 4:
Reflect on the idea that tests
are the only objective assessments of student
learning.
The suggestion that test are the only objective assessments,
laughable, if one considers that most human endeavors are at their hart
subjective. Any assessment that is
created will have a person or persons’ imprint on it. Consider new state or district assessments,
They are created by groups of people who are influenced by the world around
them. One could argue that they are reactionary in nature. If one is a resolute pessimist, it might be
suggested that they are governed by the political winds of change. But all kidding or seriousness aside, assessments
are made in order to find out how ones instruction is working. The questions are subjective based on what
the instructor thinks they need to check on.
When tests are made, they carry with them the choices made by a
person. At the university level tests
can reflect the type of student the institution wants to accept. State test design are influenced by what
leaders in industry and government deem as important at the time. According to Dr. Olenka Bilash, University of Alberta, one way to overcome the
subjective view of assessment is what she calls triangulation. Triangulation looks
at three different sources to which ensures, more accuracy of assessment
data. Three sources could include
conversations, products, and observations. Conversation can come in the form of
exit tickets or I can do statements.
Observations take place during class time and should be done by
observing small numbers of students daily, not all during a single class. Products refer to concrete items created by
students. This can include projects, tests, and tasks. Between all three a teacher can better
discern a student’s progress. All three
areas are assessed and teachers can tell whether a student knows the
information and is strong in all three areas or just one or two with the goal
bringing the students levels up in all three areas.
Reference:
Bilash,
O. (2014), Best of Bilash, Triangulation
in Assessment, retrieved from: http://www.educ.ualberta.ca/